Racial identity

RECENT POSTS

Latinos and race: How racial identity varies by generation

Source: Pew Hispanic Center, 2011 National Survey of Latinos

Today on KPCC’s Patt Morrison Show, I’ll be among the guests talking about the nuances of the pan-ethnic labels attached to people of Latin American origin in the United States, people like yours truly who are asked to identify on census forms as “Hispanic, Latino, or of Spanish Origin.”

It’s been roughly forty years since the “Hispanic” category was introduced by the U.S. Census Bureau, but a recent Pew Hispanic Center study indicates that all these years later, a majority of people described by the Hispanic/Latino label still prefer to identify according to their family’s country of origin. There are differences, depending on where people live, which immigrant generation they come from, and so forth.

And there are other interesting wrinkles in the report, including how Latinos/Hispanics/lo que sea (which loosely translates to “whatever”) identify in terms of race. Other research has found similar generational differences, but it’s fascinating: While second-generation Latinos are less likely to describe themselves as “white” than their immigrant parents are, the grandchildren of Latino immigrants are the most likely to describe themselves as white. They are also the least apt to refer to themselves as Hispanic/Latino. From the report:

Findings from the Pew Hispanic survey show that, when asked which term describes their race—white, black, Asian or some other race—51% of Latinos say their race is either “some other race” (26%) or volunteer that their race is “Hispanic or Latino” (25%).

Meanwhile, one-third (36%) say their race is white and the remainder, 10%, identify their race as black, Asian or mixed race.

…The Pew Hispanic survey also finds that racial identification among Latinos varies by immigrant generation, with third-generation Latinos the most likely to identify as white. Among immigrant Latinos, 51% say their race is “some other race” (21%) or “Hispanic or Latino” (31%),2 36% say their race is white and 9% say their race is black, Asian or mixed race.

Among second-generation Latinos, a similar pattern is evident—55% say their race is either “some other race” (36%) or “Hispanic or Latino” (20%), followed by 30% who say their race is white.

Among third-generation Hispanics, the share that identifies as white rises to 44% and the share that says “some other race” or “Hispanic or Latino” falls to 43%.

The first-second generational split isn’t surprising one. First-generation parents come to this country steeped in the Latin American hierarchy of color, in which even olive-skinned people are often considered white. Meanwhile, their children learn quickly that in the United States, the cultural definition of “white” goes beyond skin tone.

Interestingly, the Pew survey’s findings didn’t match those of the 2010 U.S. Census, which showed even more Latinos identifying as white. According to the report, 2010 census data showed that 37 percent of Latinos overall identified as “some other race” while a majority, 53 percent, identified their race as white. Then again, the census asks respondents to check the “Hispanic, Latino or of Spanish Origin” box as an ethnic category, not a racial one.

We’ll be talking about ethnic labels, identity, race and more this afternoon. The show airs between 1-3 p.m. Pacific time on KPCC 89.3 FM.

More on Latinos and race: The rise of the Latino ‘American Indian’

Photo by Leslie Berestein Rojas/KPCC

Car sticker seen on an L.A. freeway, February 2011

A recent post highlighted a Migration Policy Institute article that explored the origin of the “Hispanic, Latino or Spanish Origin” category on census forms, and in the 40 years that Latinos have been asked to identify in terms of Spanish origin, the varying ways in which they have also come to identify in terms of race.

The “Hispanic or Latino” category is an ethnic category, not a racial one. In the 2000 census, slightly under half of the 35.2 million Latinos counted reported their race as white. The rest of the racial categories they can choose from may or may not apply. Not surprisingly perhaps, 43 percent of Latinos in 2000 identified themselves as “other race.”

But a fascinating piece in the New York Times this weekend reported a rise in the number of Latinos identifying themselves as “American Indian” in the 2010 census. From the story:

Seventy percent of the 57,000 American Indians living in New York City are of Hispanic origin, according to census figures. That is 40,000 American Indians from Latin America — up 70 percent from a decade ago.

The trend is part of a demographic growth taking place nationwide of Hispanics using “American Indian” to identify their race. The number of Amerindians — a blanket term for indigenous people of the Americas, North and South — who also identify themselves as Hispanic has tripled since 2000, to 1.2 million from 400,000.

A professor of Latin American history interviewed attributed this in part to shifting migration trends, with more recent immigrants having come from regions of Latin America with large indigenous populations, such as southern Mexico and Central America.

But the census shift, if slight, is significant not only in terms of who has settled here, but how Latinos who are already here perceive and identify themselves. A second-generation Mexican American woman, Nancy Perez, explained that her family decided to go with “American Indian” because “if you go back far enough, we are indigenous:”

“We felt that there were very limited options to identify with,” Ms. Perez, 32, said. “So out of the options available, that was the best one.”