Dodger Stadium attack

RECENT POSTS

A Dodger fan on ‘the atmosphere’ at the stadium, thugs, and the Bryan Stow attack

Photo by MPR529/Flickr (Creative Commons)

Dodger Stadium during a game, May 2006

An insightful comment came in this afternoon in response to the racial tension that’s surrounded the attack on opening day at Dodger Stadium of Bryan Stow, a San Francisco Giants fan from Santa Cruz. There has been a racial undercurrent to the story since it was reported that the two suspects who violently beat Stow, who is white, were described as Latino.

Soon afterward, anti-Latino comments began appearing beneath the news reports online. This phenomenon has spread, bubbling into the mainstream via the talk-radio circuit. I wrote about this occurring in a post last Friday, which in turn generated more anti-Latino reaction. There was one comment on the site that I had to delete, which I wrote about earlier today.

In response to today’s post, a reader named Jose posted the comment below, which I’m reprinting in its entirety, with slight copyedits. While I haven’t closely followed the saga of of the team’s owners, which he writes about also, he makes interesting observations about the climate at the stadium and more:

As a Mexican-American and having grown up both a Dodger fan (dating back to 1974) and as having been raised in Northeast Los Angeles, I cannot say that the attack surprised me.

Slowly, but steadily I have witnessed the product deteriorate in terms of not only the team, but its management, and the atmosphere surrounding Dodger Stadium itself.

I am not here to give whites or any other racial or ethnic group a a free run at generalizing us, Mexicans and Mexican-Americans and Latinos in general, in terms of us being supposedly nothing but misfits and degenerates. However, the sad truth is yes, the Dodger management has allowed a certain gangster/thug element to run roughshod over the Pavilion sections as well as the parking lot. And it happens to be mainly made up of Latino gangsters and thugs.

And this is due to the bottom line of the McCourts, which is the heck with family entertainment, a good and competitive team year in and year out as well as a safe and enjoyable atmosphere before, during and after the game.

The problem has existed for a long time (what was it, Rupert Murdoch, who owned the team before the McCourts?), but has been exacerbated by the neglect to the Dodger institution by the McCourts in favor of their leveraged mansions in Malibu.

Lastly, this problem is seen in thugs of all shades and sizes and will continue to fester until someone is killed by one of these thugs and attendance/revenues fall or better yet, a new ownership comes to the Dodgers and has Chavez Ravine in focus instead of Malibu and Beverly Hills.

Blame and punish these gangster thugs with the justice system and by MLB removing the McCourts from Dodger Stadium, in that way family and class will be restored to the Dodger name and headlines…but do not vent hatred and your secret racism by attacking the Latino population of Los Angeles County, which supports in mass the Dodgers with their hard (earned) money spent on a ballgame, just like all other loyal Dodger fans.

The Dodgers held a drive-through fundraiser today for Stow, a paramedic and father who remains in a medically-induced coma and has shown signs of having sustained brain damage in the beating. No arrests have been made yet, in spite of a reward offer.

Hate speech over Dodger Stadium attack illustrates the racial tension surrounding it

Photo by The West End/Flickr (Creative Commons)

The team logo behind home plate, August 2009

The “uncomfortable racial undercurrent” I mentioned in a post Friday on the discussion surrounding the severe beating of a white San Francisco Giants fan at Dodger Stadium opening night, by two men described as Latino, has not become any more comfortable over the weekend.

In the post, I highlighted an essay from a Latino writer that addressed the racial undercurrent, which began brewing after reports described the suspected ethnicity of the men who attacked Santa Cruz paramedic Bryan Stow. I also highlighted a few of several racially charged comments posted beneath just one of the news reports, an early story on the local CBS News website.

Since Friday, the discussion has attracted more of the same on the Multi-American site. A comment from a reader identified as Leo Fryer referred to the attacks and/or violence as “part of Hispanic culture,” then went south from there, referring to Latinos as insects and calling for their being “exterminated.” I was about to take the comment down (all opinions are welcome, but the line is drawn at cursing and hate speech) when responses to it began coming in, illustrating the racial tension surrounding the attack. Here are a couple of other readers’ responses:

Seejayz responded to Fryer’s comment:

Gang banging is not latino culture. The perps aren’t illegal aliens, they are surenos gang banging punks.

Diana remarked:

WOW Ive never come across someone that has met ALL Hispanics in this world ..I’m assuming that’s why you know they are “ALL lying cheating cockroaches!”

Stow was beaten so badly he appears to have sustained brain damage. The attackers have not been caught, in spite of a reward. In the meantime, the Dodgers organization is hosting a drive-through fundraiser today at the stadium for Stow, who remains in a medically-induced coma.

Witness-based sketches of the pair were released last week, showing two men with shaved heads. The sketches themselves have elicited anti-minority reactions, targeting not just Latinos. A comment posted with the sketches on a white-pride website referred to the suspects’ “Asiatic” eyes – that’s as much as I’ll reprint – then, as might be expected, went very far south from there.

Violent hooligans have, of course, attacked people of the same race over sporting events for as long as anyone can remember, in Europe and elsewhere. But the reaction to Stow’s tragic beating in Los Angeles is typical of a city where, as multiracial as it has become, volatile racial tension continues to bubble just beneath the surface.

And on that note: Sorry, Leo. Opinions of every political stripe are welcome in the comments, but the language has to stay clean, and blatant hate speech isn’t tolerated.

Race and the Dodger Stadium attack

Photo by FoxKat/Flickr (Creative Commons)

Baseball fans at Dodger Stadium, August 2005

A couple of days ago I came across an essay that got at the heart of the uncomfortable racial undercurrent running through the discussion of last week’s senseless beating of a San Francisco Giants fan by two men at Dodger Stadium on opening night.

The victim, Bryan Stow, a Santa Cruz paramedic and father who was beaten so severely he may have brain damage, is white. The attackers, who have yet to be caught, are described as Latino. Writing for the L.A. Forward website, Tomás J. Benítez, a longtime Dodger fan and advisor to the Latino Baseball History Project of the Baseball Reliquary, took on the race issue:

Whether this was a racially motivated crime is yet to be determined, but it is possible, given that bigotry is often a characteristic of thugs—who come in all colors.

Race is a factor for all the wrong reasons. When news of the incident broke I was chagrined. It just had to be stupid Mexicans, I said to myself. A local writer made reference to Raider fans—a barely veiled, racially charged comment that infers rowdy fans from lower classes who are part of the thug culture, often Black and Brown. He was very bold to call it as he sees it, he just didn’t say what he really meant. In either case, we are both wrong. What happened was indeed one isolated incident, poorly monitored by park security, infused by booze and stupidity, and a desecration of sports to any fan—regardless of color, religion, gender or lifestyle.

Continue reading